Suggestions (beta)
Members post ideas, everyone votes with đ and đ, and staff approve, deny, or mark them as implemented or âconsideringâ with an optional reason. Every suggestion gets the serverâs own number (#1, #2, âŚ) and its own discussion thread (Discord only). A number is never used again: the server keeps a counter that only goes up, so deleting the newest suggestion does not hand its number to the next one.
Dashboard: /v2/guilds/<id>/m/suggestions - settings, a list you can filter by
status and sort by newest or most votes, and the staff actions (including
Move back).
- View Channel, Send Messages, Embed Links in the suggestions channel (and in the log channel, if you set one).
- Read Message History in both channels. On Discord Sylo edits and deletes its own posts by id, but on Fluxer it looks a message up before it deletes it. If a lookup or an edit fails for any reason other than âthe message no longer existsâ, Sylo keeps the copy it has and does not post another one.
- For threads on Discord: Create Public Threads. Without it the suggestion is posted without a thread.
- For âturn messages into suggestionsâ: Manage Messages (to delete the original) and the Message Content intent.
- No other privileged intents.
Settings
Section titled âSettingsâ-
Suggestions channel - where suggestions are posted. Empty means the channel
/suggestwas used in. Also the channel watched by the message option below. -
Log channel - optional. Where a suggestion that is approved, denied or marked implemented is also posted. What happens to the original depends on the next setting.
-
When a suggestion is decided (only used with a log channel):
- Copy to the log channel and keep the original (the default for new setups) - the suggestion stays in the suggestions channel and shows its status, reason and final votes, as it does without a log channel. Sylo also posts a copy in the log channel.
- Move to the log channel (delete the original) - Sylo reposts the suggestion in the log channel and deletes the original. The discussion thread stays where it was.
A server that had a log channel before this setting existed keeps Move, so nothing changes until you pick the other one. The dashboard always saves your choice. An older client that does not know the setting (for example an older version of the Sylo app) keeps the stored choice when it saves; if it adds a log channel to a server that has no stored choice yet, the server gets Move, because that client cannot show the choice. Open the dashboard to switch it to Copy.
-
Anonymous suggestions - new posts do not show who wrote them. The setting is fixed when a suggestion is posted, so changing it later does not change old posts. Staff still see the author on the dashboard page.
-
DM the author - on by default. The author gets a direct message when staff decide. A member with DMs closed is skipped without any message.
-
Turn messages in the channel into suggestions - off by default. When on, a plain message in the suggestions channel is deleted and posted as a suggestion instead. Messages from bots and messages with attachments are left alone (the attachment would be lost). If the message is too long, or the member is on cooldown, Sylo replies with a short note that disappears after ten seconds and leaves the message in place.
-
Cooldown - seconds a member must wait between suggestions, 0 to 3600. Default 60. 0 turns it off.
-
Staff roles - may decide on suggestions without the Manage Server permission.
Commands
Section titled âCommandsâ| Command | |
|---|---|
/suggest |
Anyone. text (up to 1000 characters) and an optional title (up to 100). On Fluxer: !suggest Add a pixel-art channel, or with a title !suggest Add a pixel-art channel title:Pixel art. |
/suggestion approve |
Staff. id and an optional reason (up to 500 characters). |
/suggestion deny |
Staff. Same options. |
/suggestion implement |
Staff. Same options. |
/suggestion consider |
Staff. Same options. |
Staff means Manage Server, Administrator, or one of the staff roles above. Sylo checks this itself, so the staff commands are visible to everyone but refuse anyone else. (Manage Events does not count here.)
How voting works
Section titled âHow voting worksâ- One vote per member. Press the other button to change your vote, or the same button again to take it back. Only you see the confirmation.
- The counts on the buttons update a few seconds after a click, so a burst of votes causes a single edit.
- The author may vote on their own suggestion.
- Approved, denied and implemented close voting: the buttons go away and the final counts stay on the post. Open and considering accept votes.
- Votes are stored in Syloâs database, not as Discord reactions.
Decisions
Section titled âDecisionsâA decision changes the embedâs colour and status line and shows the reason. Staff may decide again later (for example approved, then implemented); the latest decision and reason win. The authorâs DM says which suggestion it was, its new status and the reason.
If the post or the copy cannot be created in the log channel (missing permissions), the suggestion stays where it was and the decision still counts.
The copy in the log channel
Section titled âThe copy in the log channelâIn Copy mode Sylo remembers where the copy is:
- Only a decided suggestion (approved, denied or implemented) has a copy.
- When the status changes again (for example approved, then implemented), the copy is edited in place. If someone deleted the copy, Sylo posts a new one.
- If the suggestion goes back to open or considering, the copy is deleted.
- Deleting the suggestion on the dashboard deletes its post and its copy.
- Changing the log channel or switching to Move or to no log channel: the next decision on a suggestion removes the old copy of that suggestion. Copies of suggestions nobody decides on again stay as they are.
Move back to the suggestions channel
Section titled âMove back to the suggestions channelâSuggestions that Sylo moved to the log channel earlier (before the Copy mode, or in Move mode) stay there. On the dashboard, every suggestion whose post is not in the suggestions channel has a Move back button, and Move all back (with a confirmation) does it for all of them, oldest first. It needs a suggestions channel in the settings.
- Sylo posts the suggestion again in the suggestions channel with its number, status, reason and vote counts, and the suggestion points at the new post. Voting works there again if the suggestion is still open. No new discussion thread is opened; the old one stays where it was.
- The old post in the log channel becomes the copy in Copy mode (for a decided suggestion). In Move mode, or with no log channel, it is deleted.
- Move all back works in batches of 10, oldest first. A suggestion whose old post Sylo cannot reach is skipped and listed when the run ends; it stays where it is. On Discord, a missing Read Message History permission in the old channel causes such a skip. A temporary error, or a problem with the suggestions channel such as a missing permission, stops the run and tells you which suggestion it stopped at. Run it again after you fixed the problem; the ones already moved are not touched.
- Anyone who may use the dashboardâs staff actions (Manage Server) can do this. Sending the posts counts against the same limit as other dashboard actions that send messages (10 per minute per server).
- 1000 characters of text, 100 of title, 500 of reason.
- At most 5000 stored suggestions per server. Past that, new suggestions are refused until staff delete old ones on the dashboard (Delete removes the suggestion, its votes, its post and its copy in the log channel).
- At most 10 open suggestions (open or considering) per member at a time.
- A per-member cooldown, 60 seconds by default.
Privacy and /forget
Section titled âPrivacy and /forgetâ- A memberâs votes are deleted by
/forget. - Their suggestions stay on the serverâs board, but
/forgetremoves the author id, so the suggestion no longer points to the person. Staff decisions the member made lose their staff id as well. The text of a suggestion is kept because it belongs to the serverâs history; staff can delete it on the dashboard. - The already posted message in Discord still shows the author if the suggestion
was not anonymous.
/forgetworks on Syloâs database and does not edit old messages; the next time the post is updated (a vote, a decision) the author is left out. /mydatalists the votes, the suggestions the member wrote and the decisions they made, with counts.- The posted suggestions, their votes and the log channel posts are removed when Sylo leaves the server.
On Fluxer
Section titled âOn FluxerâFluxer has no buttons, threads or slash commands yet:
- Members vote by reacting to the suggestion: đ or đ. Sylo takes the reaction back at once; reacting with the same emoji again takes the vote back. Replies are sent as a short message that Sylo deletes after about 15 seconds.
- No discussion thread is opened (see What works differently).
- Commands run from chat with the prefix:
!suggest text:"Add a movie night",!suggestion approve id:12 reason:"Starting next week". Quote values that contain spaces. - Plain messages in the suggestions channel work the same way as on Discord.
- The dashboard works exactly as on Discord.